4.7rated over 3,700+ reviews

PieWhimsy – Spooky-Shaped Pie Maker for Festive Baking

$39.99 Was $59.99 SAVE 33%
  • Free shipping with USPS
  • 93,500+ happy customers
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

Only 4 left at this price

Ships by Free US shipping

Back to School Sale ends tonightThe more you add, the more you saveDiscounts are applied automatically in your cart

2 ITEMS10%
4 ITEMS20%

Seen on real Averndale customers

Averndale customer wearing Marsona tailored utility pants
★★★★★

“The Marsona pants sit nicely at the waist and don’t wrinkle much after sitting. Very easy to wear.”

Diane, 56 · Verified customer
Averndale customer wearing Florelle layered ruffle dress
★★★★★

“Ordered from Averndale for a family lunch. The dress felt dressed-up without feeling tight.”

Margaret, 64 · Verified customer
Averndale customer wearing Breezlin summer capris
★★★★★

“The Breezlin capris are light and don’t cling around my hips. The pockets are actually useful too.”

Angela, 52 · Verified customer
Averndale customer wearing Veluna crossover midi dress
★★★★★

“First time buying from Averndale. It arrived nicely packed and the fit was better than I expected.”

Grace, 59 · Verified customer
Product details +

Whip up Halloween magic in every bite

If you wait until October to get spooky, you're already late.

True Halloween fans feel the excitement as soon as the leaves change—and nothing kicks off the season like the smell of warm, buttery pie crust filling your home.


With PieWhimsy, you don't just bake—you bring storybook magic to life.

Each adorable press shapes your creations into pumpkins, apples, or little acorns, making treats that look like they popped right out of your favorite fall fairy tale.

Whether you're baking for a classroom, hosting a cozy get-together, or just treating yourself with a warm blanket and a cup of tea, this is where the spooky season truly begins.

Loved by early-bird Halloween bakers all across America

Add a touch of Halloween magic
Every pie comes out looking like it belongs in a fairy tale—perfect for cozy nights, festive fall mornings, and getting into those early Halloween vibes.


Make festive treats in under 60 seconds
Just cut, fill, and seal your pies in a single smooth step—no tricky tools, no mess, just pure baking joy.


3 whimsical shapes to delight every guest
Pumpkin, apple, and acorn designs turn everyday snacks into showstopping seasonal treats worth sharing.


No burnt fingers or sticky dough
The ergonomic, non-slip press with smooth, finger-safe edges makes it effortless and fun—perfect for kids and adults alike.

Hit "Add to Cart" now to get 2+1 free on PieWhimsy! This special offer is only available for a limited time!

What people think

Frequently asked questions

Can I use this with puff pastry or biscuit dough?
Yes, it works beautifully with both. Just be sure the dough is rolled evenly to avoid overfilling.

Do the pies stay sealed during baking?
They do—the double crimp hinge presses tight, keeping all your filling inside and edges neat.

Are the shapes suitable for other holidays?
Absolutely! The apple and acorn shapes are perfect for fall baking, not just Halloween.

Is this safe for kids to use?
Yes, the press edges are sturdy but finger-safe. Adult supervision is still best for very young helpers.

How to use

  • Roll out your pastry dough evenly.
  • Open the PieWhimsy and press the base onto the dough to cut your shape.
  • Place one piece of dough inside the press, add your filling, then place the second dough piece on top.
  • Close to seal—then bake as usual!

Specifications

  • Size: Approx. 4.1 x 3.3 x 1.7 in (varies slightly by shape)
  • Material: Food-grade BPA-free ABS plastic
Shipping & returns +

Free tracked US shipping. Estimated delivery dates are shown at checkout.

Returns are accepted in line with the store's published refund policy.

Combine & save up to 20% extra

Shop all

Our customers say it better than we do

★★★★★

Returning customer

I've bought numerous items from Averndale over the years because I know it will be good quality at a reasonable price, along with looking modern and expensive. Never been disappointed.

Emma K.Emma K. · 6 hours ago●  Verified purchase
★★★★★

The wife loves it

I bought a birthday gift for my wife, and she absolutely loved it! The quality is fantastic, and it was exactly what she wanted. Highly recommend!

Geoffrey L.Geoffrey L. · 1 day ago●  Verified purchase
★★★★★

Recommended by a friend

A friend told me that she found Averndale on Pinterest and convinced me to buy the same thing. Super happy with my purchase — great service and fast shipping.

Amara O.Amara O. · 1 day ago●  Verified purchase

We're Averndale — where women with good taste find what they love

Bags that get compliments. Dresses that just work. Home pieces that make a room feel finished. All designed to look like more than you paid.

That's the Averndale feeling — and you deserve that.

A few times a year, we open up our best prices as a thank you to our customers, and a welcome to new ones. Consider this our gift to you.

Right now, selected favorites are available at some of our best prices. Only while this offer lasts.

Women from the Averndale community with their orders
PieWhimsy – Spooky-Shaped Pie Maker for Festive Baking$39.99